dalekboy: (10th Doctor)
([personal profile] dalekboy Dec. 27th, 2009 12:23 am)
Given that once it was downloaded I wasn't desperate to watch it immediately, you should have some idea of just how low I had set the bar. So I had seriously low expectations...

And I was still disappointed.

It really is a mess. It has moments and elements that I liked, but they are all too brief and mostly come at the end. I really hoped RTD would return to form and give us something approaching the levels of Rose, The End of the World, Parting of the Ways or Doomsday. Either a simple, well realised story, or a proper, amazing finale.

Not even close. If I had seen any of those episodes and then you'd shown me this one, and I didn't know it was written by the same man, I would never have believed it.

He's got a hell of a lot of ground to make up with part 2. I don't think he's going to, but I'd genuinely like to be posting this time next week saying that it was not only a fabulous send off to the Tenth Doctor, but an amazing and brilliant send off to Russell and his team.

2/10



Any comments to this post are likely to contain massive spoilers, so please be warned.

From: [identity profile] angriest.livejournal.com


I started off hating it immensely, then liking it quite a bit in the middle - when the Doctor and the Master got to have a conversation for a minute - and then by the end it was completely and totally silly.

To be honest the entire episode, once finished, felt entirely like padding to build up to the events of next week's ep.
.

Profile

dalekboy: (Default)
dalekboy

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags